Industry coalition calls for recognition of licensing markets, transparency in AI training, and protection of creators' rights.
October 30, 2026 — The Digital Media Leadership Alliance (DMLA) has joined a coalition of creative industry and technology organizations in filing an amicus curiae brief in In re OpenAI, Inc. Copyright Infringement Litigation, the consolidated federal copyright litigation involving OpenAI and Microsoft.
The brief, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, supports the plaintiffs' motions for summary judgment and opposes the defendants' motions. It addresses fundamental questions about the use of copyrighted works in artificial intelligence systems, the application of fair use, and the importance of licensing and transparency. Led by the AI Coalition for Data Integrity (AICDI), the participating organizations include DMLA, the Writers Guild of America East and West, the National Association of Voice Actors, Microstocksolutions, the Association of Medical Illustrators, and other creative industry representatives.
Protecting the Value of Copyrighted Content
At the center of the brief is the argument that AI innovation should not come at the expense of the individuals and businesses that create, curate, license, and distribute the copyrighted content on which AI systems depend. The coalition challenges the position that licensing copyrighted works for AI training is impractical or that the use of such works should automatically qualify as fair use. The brief points to an established and expanding marketplace for AI content licensing, including more than 120 publicly reported licensing agreements, as evidence that commercial arrangements are both feasible and increasingly common.
For DMLA members, this issue is particularly significant. Photographs, illustrations, editorial imagery, video, and other professionally produced digital assets represent substantial creative and financial investments. The ability to license these works, establish their provenance, and negotiate appropriate compensation is essential to the sustainability of the digital media industry.
Key Arguments Presented to the Court
The coalition advances several important principles:
Licensing markets must be recognized. Existing and emerging markets for AI training data demonstrate that copyrighted content has commercial value and that unauthorized use can affect licensing opportunities.
Transparency and provenance matter. AI developers should maintain records identifying the content used to build their systems. Such documentation supports copyright accountability, responsible data practices, and AI security.
Different AI uses require separate consideration. The acquisition of copyrighted works, model training, retrieval or grounding, and the generation of outputs are distinct activities that should be evaluated individually under copyright law.
Opt-out mechanisms are not a substitute for licensing. Technical controls do not necessarily prevent all unauthorized uses and cannot readily reverse the incorporation of works already used in training.
Responsible licensing supports innovation. A sustainable marketplace for professionally created content helps ensure the continued production of reliable, high-quality material on which future AI systems depend.
The brief also addresses national security arguments raised in the litigation, asserting that documented and responsibly sourced training data can strengthen AI security rather than impede technological progress.
Why This Matters for DMLA Members
The outcome of this litigation could have far-reaching implications for how copyrighted material is acquired, used, and licensed in AI systems. For visual media companies, the questions extend beyond model training. They include how content is accessed for AI-powered search, how images and other assets are incorporated into generated responses, and whether existing and emerging licensing markets receive appropriate consideration under copyright law.
The coalition asks the court to recognize that lawful access, transparent data practices, and viable licensing markets are important components of responsible AI development.
The court has not yet ruled on the fair-use issues addressed in the brief.
DMLA Advocacy in Action
DMLA's participation reflects the organization’s ongoing commitment to ensuring that digital media rights holders have a voice in the legal and policy discussions shaping the future of artificial intelligence. Working alongside organizations representing writers, performers, illustrators, publishers, and other creative professionals strengthens the industry's collective voice on issues that affect the creation, ownership, licensing, and distribution of copyrighted content.
As AI technologies continue to evolve, DMLA will remain engaged in efforts to promote copyright protections, transparency, fair compensation, and a sustainable marketplace for creative content.